Not at the head of the class

New study gives Texas a mediocre grade for teaching environment

New study gives Texas a mediocre grade for teaching environment

Teacher with young students
Those who can, teach. Educational First Steps/Facebook

If Texas were a student, it would earn a middle-of-the-pack grade when it comes to the state’s atmosphere for schoolteachers. In a new study from personal finance website WalletHub, Texas ranks 19th for its teaching environment compared with the 49 other states and the District of Columbia.

While Texas earns good marks for teacher salaries, the rest of the state’s grades for teachers are below average, according to WalletHub. In all, WalletHub studied 22 metrics to come up with its report card.

Texas ranks second for the average starting salary for teachers (adjusted for cost of living), and 13th for the average salary for teachers (also adjust for cost of living) as well as for the 10-year change in teachers’ salaries, WalletHub says. Texas doesn’t fare nearly as well in WalletHub’s other measurements, though:

  • No. 29 for pupil-teacher ratio.
  • No. 30 for teacher safety.
  • No. 32 for fewest teachers per student projected for 2026.
  • No. 36 for school quality.
  • No. 36 for per-student spending in public schools. According to the National Education Association (NEA), per-student funding in Texas is $2,300 less than the national average. 
  • No. 37 for teachers’ potential for income growth.

A recent survey by the Texas State Teachers Association backs up the notion that the state’s teachers aren’t in the same class as their counterparts in places like New York, Connecticut, Minnesota, and Illinois, which were graded by WalletHub as the best states for teachers.

For instance, the Texas survey indicates that about four of every 10 teachers expect to take jobs outside the classroom to make ends meet during the academic year. In addition, the typical teacher in the survey reported spending an average of $738 a year on school supplies out of his or her own pocket.

According to the survey, moonlighting teachers in Texas average 14.1 hours a week at their extra jobs. That’s on top of the 17 hours a week they spend outside the classroom on school-related work. 

The Austin-based Texas State Teachers Association, an affiliate of the NEA, says the average salary of teachers in the survey was $53,221, which is $7,300 below the national average. According to the NEA, Texas ranks 29th for teacher pay. 

Noel Candelaria, president of the Texas association, pins the blame for the plight of Texas teachers on Gov. Greg Abbott, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, and their legislative allies. He says they’ve failed to properly finance public education.

“Our teachers … remain dedicated to their students’ success, even if it means spending evenings and weekends at extra jobs away from their families,” Candelaria says in a release. “It’s time for our elected officials at the state Capitol to demonstrate the same kind of dedication to our children by providing the necessary resources.”

In August, Abbott said he wants to boost pay for the state’s best teachers, putting them on a path toward earning more than $100,000 a year—without a hike in property taxes.

“Teaching is a calling; it would be hard to do otherwise,” Abbott said. “But I want to ensure that teaching in Texas also becomes a profession, where we are able to attract the very best and keep the very best.”

“We can and we must do more to improve education in Texas,” the governor said. “As we approach this next legislative session [in 2019], one of my top goals is to improve education by investing more in our teachers and students.”