Mondo Wuz Robbed
Michael Kors & Nina Garcia lose their minds; Gretchen wins Project Runway
- Gretchen Jones
- Would you wear this? Gretchen Jones' first look
- Mondo Guerra's first look - much more polished and fun
- This is the gown that offended Kors & GarciaFrazer Harrison/Getty Images for Mercedes-Benz
- In comments section, a CultureMap reader asked to see this incomprehensible lookfrom Jones' collection. Kors & Garcia thought it was cutting-edge.
- Mondo Guerra might actually get more attention by coming in No. 2
Project Runway has always been the reality show that made sense, with a string of winners, including Houston's Chloe Dao, who were talented and deserving.
But the show lost all credibility when "Granola Gretchen" Jones was named the winner of Season 8 Thursday night.
Blame it on Michael Kors and Nina Garcia.
The duo, who have reached celebrity status as judges on Project Runway, are usually right on in their fashion assessments. But as they piled praise on Jones' embarassing sportswear collection, I wondered if their fashion sensibility had been abducted by aliens — or buyers at Marshall's.
Kors and Garcia argued that Jones' dour collection — autumn-hued dresses, ill-fitting hot pants, slacks with faux-lizard cutouts around the crotch and inside of the legs — is where fashion is headed. They praised Jones' forged silver jewelry — something you might find at a weekend swap shop — and tired-looking fedoras as examples of exemplary styling.
Their illogical but fierce arguments seemed to finally wear down host Heidi Klum and guest judge Jessica Simpson, who much preferred the whimsical styles of season favorite Mondo Guerra.
Guerra's wild collection is what fashion should be — fun, exciting, eye-catching — and wearable. Kors and Garcia seemed to be mightily offended that Guerra hadn't removed a sensational, slinky black-and-white polka dotted gown that was the highlight of his collection. Guerra stuck to his guns, which was probably why he lost out in the shocking outcome.
I'll admit that Guerra has done better work throughout the season, but his cohesive collection was head and shoulders over Jones's effort and everyone else's.
Garcia, fashion editor at Marie Claire, complained that Guerra's collection was "too young" — a surprising complaint from a magazine that regularly dresses up teenage models to look far older than their years.
Kors, whose collections have grown increasingly more conservative during the recession, touted Jones' collection because he believes it is more saleable.
I guess it's a sign of the times. Why award creativity? Much better to play it safe and encourage mediocrity.
They could have encouraged a budding John Galliano.
Instead they championed Dress 4 Less.