Hoops City
Don't punish Jimmer Fredette for sex: A Selection Sunday that hinges on thebedroom
Jimmer Fredette hasn't had sex with his girlfriend (or anyone else) since he's been enrolled at BYU. At least, as far as anyone knows.
So why is there a good chance Fredette — who became the curious haircut face of this college basketball season months ago — will still be punished for it by the NCAA?
Welcome to Selection Sunday for the NCAA Tournament that leads to Houston, the first Selection Sunday ever that's most pressing question centers on the bedroom. Ever since 6-foot-9 BYU forward Brandon Davies was suspended from one of the top teams in the country for having premarital sex, a violation of the honor code mandated for the university by its owner and governing body, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the most pressing and compelling question for the tournament selection committee became where it would seed BYU.
Sometimes, timing really is everything.
With the field expanded to 68 teams for the first time this year — with four play-in games set for Tuesday and Wednesday in the NCAA's new First Four, including two between major conference teams — and a dearth of depth in the college game this year, the customary whining about the teams whose bubbles burst figures to be much more muted than usual Sunday evening. The four No. 1 overall seeds are already all but locked in as well — Ohio State, Kansas, Pittsburgh and the winner of Sunday's North Carolina-Duke ACC title game. The No. 2 seeds carry a little more mystery, but a lot of it centers on BYU.
The North Carolina-Duke loser and Notre Dame are otherwise pretty secure. Texas has a shot at a two, but needs to pull for Florida to lose in the SEC Championship Game Sunday.
Where's the real drama? Back with the BYU dilemma.
There's no question that the Cougars built a resume deserving of a No. 2 seed at worst. They are a 30-4 team that beat the team it lost to in Saturday night's Mountain West Conference Championship Game twice in the regular season, including a dominant win on San Diego State's home floor. Yet, there is also no question that BYU is not close to the same team without Davies. The Cougars have gone 3-2 without their lifeline big man and Fredette had to go legend and drop 52 points on an average New Mexico team to even drag BYU over .500 post sexgate.
But can the Selection Committee really punish the BYU players in good conscience when the team's diminished status comes from an archaic university rule?
I say no. BYU must be a No. 2 seed by the time Charles Barkley calls somebody stupid for the first time on CBS.
The Mormon school (the one where Jim McMahon apparently had no trouble toeing the Honor Code line, which also forbids coffee) probably lost any realistic shot at making it to Houston for the Final Four when Davies was told his season was over. But that doesn't mean the players who worked so hard to have that chance, shouldn't get the path they earned to attempt it. A No. 2 seed holds even more advantages over a No. 3 seed than a No. 1 does over a No. 2.
You want to be on those first two lines. And that's where the Selection Committee needs to place Jimmer. It's about more than numbers, but that's where the stand needs to start.