Editor's Note: In the second annual CultureMap Auto Awards, our automotive correspondents Nic Phillips and Kevin McCauley bestow honors in 10 categories for the top cars and trucks of 2013/2014 and explain why they're deserving of a good hard look. For our third award of the year:
Smart Energy Vehicle of the Year: 2014 Mazda 6 SKYACTIV with i-ELOOP
Sometimes taking a good hard look and making what is "old" new again while getting back to basics yields the greatest innovations and that's precisely what Mazda has done with its Mazda 6 midsize sedan. The sexy shaped 6 isn't an electric or a hybrid, there is no plug and its engine runs on regular, not premium gas. Yet at its top-level trim, the car delivers downright diesel-like economy of 28 MPG city/40 highway. That's with an automatic transmission — the manual actually gets slightly lower ratings.
Wait — that all seems backwards, a true midsize car running regular gas in an engine mated to an automatic in its most luxurious trim getting the best efficiency? That's SKYACTIV — Mazda's brand of a holistic approach to designing cars that squeeze every ounce of efficiency without sacrificing the drive or design.
Sometimes taking a good hard look and making what is "old" new again while getting back to basics yields the greatest innovations.
It's a philosophy where the chassis, engine, transmission and the recovery of otherwise wasted energy are designed in harmony to deliver near hybrid efficiency without electrification, complex battery systems and boring dynamics.
While not a hybrid per say, the Mazda 6's i-ELOOP technology is sort-of is like a hybrid in that it captures electric energy from the brakes. Rather than store that energy in battery, i-ELOOP very quickly charges a capacitor bank and rather than driving an electric motor to move the car, the energy used to power its electric systems normally taxing the gas engine. The result is more horsepower to move the wheels, less fuel used for the lights and steering. That's SKYACTIV.
Mazda 6 is smart energy and smart value too with highest priced Grand Touring trim with the all-in GT Technology Package coming in at $32,570 including luxury and safety features like radar cruise control, active collision alert and Smart City Braking, lane departure warning and automatic high beam HID headlights — features not found on many cars costing twice the price.
Smart Energy Vehicle Runner-up: 2014 Volkswagen Jetta Hybrid
VW does have a reputation for being different, stepping to its own beat with the Jetta Hybrid the Germans don't disappoint. Where most sub-$30k hybrids have puny engines augmented by weak electric motors and transmissions with no speeds, just a continuously variable noise makers, the Jetta has a turbo and a 7-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission — the first in a hybrid.
The DSG® Transmission is simply marvelous delivering precise, manual-like shifts nearly instantaneously and when coupled with its innovative hybrid module — a single, integrated unit that incorporates both the electric motor and a clutch that connects it to the engine, acceleration is smooth and torque constant. Several drive modes allow for all electric drive up to 44 MPH or a "active boost" mode gives full turbo-engine and electric assist for more spirited performance. All of this efficiency intelligence is presented to the driver by way of special power gauge that replaces what is normally the tachometer making for the most clear and concise status display of any hybrid out there.
So why is the Jetta Hybrid not an overall winner? Price.
It's about $4,000 more than the already fuel frugal Jetta TDI Clean Diesel and while the Hybrid is the most fuel efficient VW with an EPA estimated 42 MPG city/48 highway rating, it requires premium gas making for a longish return on investment.